Cleveland
Institute of Art – From Art to Part
to Pope
Matthew Hollern was a student at the
Tyler School of Art when his class became
the first in the country to be taught
CAD/CAM technology in a jewelry design
master’s program. The lessons he
learned back then did not fall on deaf
ears. From 1989, when he joined the Cleveland
Institute of Art faculty, until 2001,
shortly before he became the Dean of the
Craft Environment, he spent a good portion
of his time at trying to put together
a complete CAD/CAM system for teaching
jewelry design and manufacturing. Sure
there were a lot of potential candidates,
but Professor Hollern was looking for
something that was feasible pedagogically
and economically both for the school and
ultimately for the individual graduate
(in academia, this also means fundable).
Then in the summer of 2000, McNeel and
Associates, makers of Rhino 3D modeling
software offered a workshop for jewelry
designers, hosted by Roland, makers of
desktop milling machines. This is where
he first became aware of a CAM product
from MecSoft called VisualMill, which
was taught on the final day of the 5-day
workshop. Seeing how well the three products
worked together, Professor Hollern decided
that he could bring the same tools to
the Cleveland Institute of Art, so he
wrote up a grant proposal. Within a year,
the grant was funded and the Professor
purchased the Roland MDX 550 as well as
lab licenses for VisualMill and Rhino.
First “Minor” Project
Not long after everything was set up,
in the fall of 2001, a representative
of John Carroll University, located in
a Cleveland suburb, contacted the Institute
to see if someone would be interested
in designing and manufacturing a new award
that they wished to present to Pope John
Paul II, called The Global Champion of
Freedom Award. Professor Hollern accepted
the project and began to design the award
with his wife, Pamela Argentieri.
While he had been learning the CAD/CAM
system for the past few months, this would
be the first finished project Professor
Hollern would attempt with his new package.
He and Pamela started with paper models
and conceptual designs in Rhino, and eventually
created prototype models in foam, wax,
wood and aluminum using the Roland mill
driven by VisualMill (see figure 1). He
also used VisualMill to machine the actual
base of the award – which had a
bronze history plate engraved and seated
in the bottom of the pewter base.
Figure 1 –
This image shows an early wax prototype
of the award created by Professor
Hollern and Pamela Argentieri, and
machined with VisualMill.
The top of the award was fabricated
and gilded with 24K Gold leaf (see figure
2). At times he needed technical assistance
from VisualMill, and recalled one instance
when the president of MecSoft called him
from home on a Saturday to help get him
through a quandary. “That’s
what I call customer service,” noted
Professor Hollern, adding that the other
times when he needed the assistance of
technical support, someone was always
very helpful. They must have been, because
within a few weeks the award was manufactured
(see figure 3) and he and his wife were
at the Vatican to see the presentation
of it to the Pope in December 2001 (see
figure 4).
Figure 2 –
In a short time period, design of
the award progressed to this stage,
which is close to its final appearance.
Figure 3 –
The final award as manufactured in
VisualMill.
Figure 4 –
Professor Hollern and his wife went
to Rome to present the award to the
Pope in December of 2001.
A New Way to Craft
Since that dramatic first project, Professor
Hollern has continued to work VisualMill
into the courses that he teaches at the
Cleveland Institute of Art. Currently
he is teaching his students to make molds
and cut finished parts with VisualMill
and says that "the students have
taken to it pretty well – they understand
the program’s different parameters
including the different types of cutting
strategies, materials, cutters, and so
on.”
“While craftsmen working in materials
like ceramic, glass and metal have always
been associated with using their hands,
I find it exciting and provocative to
say that you don’t really need your
hands – the design comes from the
head. Some are troubled with this and,
frankly, I’m glad that they are.
But the point is that the arguments in
class are about design and how to create
good design – not about which software
command to use,” he said.
“When you see a crafted object you
have a sense of the time period that it
came from – and it should be the
same with digital tools. The only difference
is that the bits and bytes are the medium
and you are manipulating it in a different
way,” he added. Professor Hollern
gave an example of this – how one
students’ design was influenced
by a toolpath pattern that VisualMill
displayed on the screen (see figure 5).
The Professor explained that “some
toolpaths are quite beautiful –
so much that they actually become part
of the ornamental design. Basically the
patterns become decorations, thus allowing
the process to be seen and expressed.
It speaks about how it came about, which
is what contemporary craft can do.”
Figure 5 –
Toolpaths that VisualMill created
inspired artistic details for some
of the students at the Cleveland Institute
of Art.
The Results
It is always said that if you enjoy what
you do, the results will show up in your
work, and this has been the case at the
Cleveland Institute of Art. The Professor
talked about students who have won scholarships
based on designs they created since this
system was introduced (see figure 6 and
7). “In fact, in the first semester
of using this technology, from an entire
graduating class of 98 students, in which
there were only three from my department,
two of them finished in 1st and 3rd place
for a post-graduate travel award,”
he said proudly (see figure 8).
Professor Hollern concluded with these
thoughts: “I am not teaching VisualMill,
I am teaching jewelry design, with VisualMill
just being one of the tools. I am not
trying to turn them into machinists, and
because VisualMill is so easy to use,
it doesn’t have to become the subject
of an entire class.” Now if only
more teachers had this philosophy and
the tools to back them up, perhaps more
students would be interested in careers
in design and crafts, rather than just
sports and law.
Figure 6
– Detail of design from student
Kyle Bradford that was machine with
VisualMill.
Figure 7
– Collection of student designs
created in Professor Hollern’s
jewelry design and manufacturing class
at the Cleveland Institute of Art.
Figure
8 – Students Land and
Wuttig won an award at the Cleveland
Institute of Art for their design
of this puzzle, seen here.